Go Home! Go Idol!


American Idol, Season 3 - Week By Week

Wow, I can't believe how good this group is as a whole. There were really only 3 people last year that would've sounded good mixed in with this group. It's almost impossible to rank these performances, so many of them were simply amazing. From here on out there will be 2 rankings listed, the first the overall ranking, taking into consideration all the performances they've put on thus far, and the second simply how they stood up against the rest on this day alone. And now to it...

George Pic1-1. George Huff: Wow I love george. Doesn't get any better than that. He came incredibly, disturbingly close to improving on one of the best vocal performances of all time. So excellent. Beyond excellent. Go George, go. Wow.
Tasia Pic2-2. Fantasia Barrino: Wow has she got an amazing voice. Amazing performance, and she just tosses it off like nothing, effortless. It probably sounded just that good the first time she sang it. Simply amazing. And amazing. Almost a bit... amazing. And ya can't go wrong with Stevie.
Jen Pic3-5. Jennifer Hudson: Outstanding voice. Tons of power, but tons of control to match it. Not much else to say, great job.
LaToya Pic4-6. LaToya London: Blah, really didn't like this song at all. Decent performance, definitely better in the higher octave. Beginning was a bit shaky, and she was running out of breath at the end, but everything in between was solid. Good. (The judges certainly liked it more than I did...)
Diana Pic5-3. Diana DeGarmo: Wonderful performance. Excellent, high energy, wonderfully sung. Couldn't quite reach a few of the low notes, but no biggie. As a sidenote, really liked her hair that way, cute.
Jon Pic6-8. Jon Peter Lewis: Alright, the dancing's cool and all, but not when it starts affecting the singing. It also felt really forced this time, like he was only doing it cause it worked last time and why not. Meh, it wasn't terrible, but not particularly good either...
Jasmine Pic7-4. Jasmine Trias: Simply excellent. Just a couple of minor pitch mishaps, but even they were quickly smoothed out mid-note. Very very nice.
Matt Pic8-7. Matt Rogers: Good performance, lots of energy and attitude. The singing was pretty safe, didn't really put too much into it. Safe, albeit good, performance.
Leah Pic9-11. Leah LaBelle: Meh, it wasn't great, but certainly not as terrible as Simon thought. Really don't get the song choice, there are so many excellent soul songs that would have fit her perfectly, but that song was really empty. Just not much to it, vocally. Meh.
Camille Pic10-10. Camille Velasco: Beginning was definitely a bit low on her, and I'm not sure she ever quite recovered from that. It was ok, but nothing really special. The intro package, as well, was INCREDIBLY empty, bored the hell out of me. Meh.
Amy Pic11-9. Amy Adams: Wow, that dog noise she did in the intro was really awesome! Then an alright performance. She's got a really soft, sweet voice most of the time. Can get a bit pitchy in her upper range, but good nonetheless. A'ight...
John Pic12-12. John Stevens: ... I can't listen to this guy anymore. It was ok once, alright twice, and now I'm just bored nearly to death. He's pitchy, dull, and blah. As for the 'you can't compare them, they're different artists' bull, it's just that, bull. You sure as hell can compare, he sucks, the rest don't. Blah. I agree with Randy. And he sucks, and I don't like it, and I'm done.

© Brandon Baither, 2004, Keep Yo Dirty Paws Off (not like you wanna steal this junx anyway)